Civil Rights Update: Supreme Court Establishes New Title VII Standard

Posted by HLL Admin

The U.S. Supreme Court recently ruled on a longstanding issue regarding the harm necessary for an employment discrimination claim under Title VII of the Civil Rights Act. In Muldrow v. City of St. Louis, the Court determined that a plaintiff need only demonstrate “some” harm, rather than “significant” harm, from an employment decision to prove employment discrimination under Title VII. This decision resolves a circuit split that previously required plaintiffs in certain jurisdictions to show “serious” or “materially adverse” harm. But how much does this really clarify standards for employers? 

Understand the Case

The case involved Jatonya Muldrow, a Sergeant with the St. Louis Police Department, who was transferred to a different division within the department. Despite her rank and salary remaining the same, Muldrow alleged that the transfer resulted in negative changes to her working conditions and responsibilities. She filed a Title VII discrimination claim, arguing that the transfer constituted adverse employment action based on her sex. However, the lower courts dismissed her claim, applying the Eighth Circuit’s “materially significant disadvantage” standard.

New Title VII Standard Established

The Supreme Court’s decision in Muldrow v. City of St. Louis establishes a new standard for employment discrimination claims under Title VII of the Civil Rights Act. Hence, this landmark ruling sets a precedent that plaintiffs need only demonstrate “some harm” from an adverse employment action to plead and prove discrimination. The Court’s opinion, authored by Justice Kagan, clarifies that this harm need not be “significant” or meet any heightened threshold, but rather must relate to an identifiable term or condition of employment. This new standard provides a universally lower bar for Title VII plaintiffs, streamlining the process for bringing discrimination claims and ensuring that even minor instances of harm are recognized and addressed.

Implications for Employers

This decision carries significant implications for employers across the nation. By establishing a lower threshold for harm in Title VII discrimination claims, the ruling increases the likelihood of employees successfully challenging adverse employment actions. As a result, employers must closely scrutinize transfer decisions and other managerial actions to ensure they do not result in any harm to the employee, no matter how minor. This heightened scrutiny requires employers to carefully assess the terms and conditions of employment for affected individuals and mitigate any potential negative repercussions. Access to legal guidance becomes crucial for navigating these complexities and ensuring compliance with Title VII regulations. Additionally, employers must proactively review their policies and practices to minimize the risk of discrimination claims and protect their workforce from legal challenges.

At Hughes Lawyers LLC, we understand the complexities of employment law and discrimination claims. Our experienced team of attorneys specializes in providing strategic legal guidance to employers facing employment-related challenges. With the Muldrow decision altering the landscape of Title VII claims, it’s crucial for employers to have access to knowledgeable legal counsel. We’re here to provide the support and expertise you need to protect your business interests and navigate the ever-changing legal environment. Don’t hesitate to reach out to us for personalized legal assistance tailored to your specific needs.

Update on Noncompete Agreements:...

Noncompete agreements and their implementation have long been a source of argument and rulemaking in employment law. On April 23, 2024, the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) made a significant decision. It voted 3-2 to issue its final rule banning employers from imposing noncompete clauses on their workers. This decision came after more than 15 months

Read more…

West Virginia Law Aims...

A new trucking liability law has arrived. West Virginia’s recent enactment of legislation imposing a cap on noneconomic damage awards in civil lawsuits involving commercial motor vehicles has stirred considerable discussion within the trucking industry. As legal advisors specializing in transportation law, Hughes Lawyers, LLC, recognizes the significance of this development and the implications it

Read more…

Civil Rights Update: Supreme...

The U.S. Supreme Court recently ruled on a longstanding issue regarding the harm necessary for an employment discrimination claim under Title VII of the Civil Rights Act. In Muldrow v. City of St. Louis, the Court determined that a plaintiff need only demonstrate “some” harm, rather than “significant” harm, from an employment decision to prove

Read more…

Contact Us






    The content of this website is presented for general informational purposes only. Every effort has been made to ensure the website's accuracy however there is no guarantee that the content provided herein is correct, complete, and up-to-date.

    This website is not intended to be a source of legal advice nor should it be considered as legal advice. The reader should not rely on the information presented on this website and should always seek the advice of competent counsel licensed to practice in the state in which the reader resides. Transmission of information on this website does not create an attorney-client relationship with Hughes Lawyers, LLC or with Steven Hughes and Joseph Hoffman individually. The firm assumes no liability for the interpretation and/or use of the information contained on the website, nor does it offer a warranty of any kind, either expressed or implied.

    The use of email, including the contact form on this website, for confidential or sensitive information is discouraged. If the reader chooses to send an email with confidential or sensitive information, reader accepts the risks of lack of confidentiality.

    The choice of a lawyer is an important decision and should not be based solely on advertisements.

    © 2021 Hughes Lawyers, LLC | All Rights Reserved